Looking for easy Christmas cookie tray ideas? Skip the scoop this year! These 6 holiday treats are all made in one pan, then sliced, cut, or broken into pieces, so you get a full cookie tray without scooping (or rolling) a single cookie.

If you've ever stood at the counter scooping dozens of cookies, baking batch after batch while your kitchen fills up with cooling racks, this list is for you. Every recipe here goes into one pan. Once it's baked (or chilled), you cut it into shapes or squares and you're done.
This one-pan method is the whole idea behind my cookbook, One Crafty Pan.
Why Skip the Scoop?
- One pan, one bake. No rotating cookie sheets in and out of the oven.
- No scooping a million cookies!
- Great for gifting. Bars and bark stack and travel much better than round cookies.
1. Christmas Tree Cookie Cake Bars

One pan of my chewy chocolate chip cookie cake, sliced into triangles and turned into a whole forest of Christmas trees! Pipe on green frosting and a little yellow star and you've got a tray full of trees from one batch of dough.
2. Puppy Chow Bark

All the flavor of puppy chow without the giant bowl or the sticky fingers. Layers of chocolate-peanut butter and Chex cereal set up in a 9x13 pan, get a dusting of powdered sugar, and break into pieces that are perfect for holiday platters.
It's no-bake, so it's a great one to make when your oven is already working overtime.
3. Snickerdoodle Gingerbread Men

Soft, chewy snickerdoodle cookie bars coated in cinnamon sugar, baked in one pan and cut out with a gingerbread man cookie cutter. No rolling, no chilling, and no scooping!
Pipe on a simple cinnamon frosting for the classic gingerbread look, or leave them plain. The frosting firms up so they stack nicely on a cookie tray.
4. Peanut Butter Blossom Bars

A soft (yet sturdy!) peanut butter bar that slices cleanly and is made for sharing or gifting, without scooping a single cookie.
This one is an exclusive recipe from my cookbook, One Crafty Pan. Pop your email in on the recipe page and I'll send it straight to your inbox so you can try my one-pan method for free.
5. Oreo Truffle Bars

Love Oreo truffles but hate rolling and dipping each one? Same. These bars press the creamy Oreo truffle filling into one pan, then top it with a white chocolate peppermint layer and crushed candy canes.
Chill, slice, and you've got a whole pan of truffles with zero dipping.
6. Christmas Sugar Cookie Bars (1 Pan, 4 Ways!)

My most popular Frosted Sugar Cookie Bars, turned into four Christmas designs from ONE 9x13 pan: Santa hats, candy canes, presents, and snowmen.
You frost half the pan white and half red, then cut using my diagram. It looks like a whole day of cookie decorating, but it's one pan of dough and a couple bowls of frosting.
Tips for Skip-the-Scoop Baking
- Spray, then line with parchment. A little cooking spray under the parchment keeps it from sliding, and the parchment lets you lift the whole slab out to cut it.
- Drop the dough in chunks. Instead of plopping it all in the middle, drop small chunks across the pan, then press it flat with a spatula or sprayed hands.
- Don't overbake. Pull bars when the edges are just barely golden. They keep baking in the hot pan and stay soft.
- Cool completely before cutting. For the cleanest shapes, let the bars cool all the way (or chill the no-bake ones) before slicing.
- Use a big knife or cookie cutters. Wipe the blade (or cutter) between cuts for clean edges.
Christmas Cookie Tray Ideas & Gifting Tips
All of these are perfect for neighbor gifts, teacher gifts, and cookie exchanges. Stack a few pieces in a treat box or cello bag, tie it with baker's twine, and add a tag. Members of the Crafty Bakers Club get printable Christmas tags and packaging to match!
Want more one-pan holiday treats? You'll find more (plus cutting diagrams for shapes like these) in One Crafty Pan.

