Mini Caramel Cheesecake Bites

Caramel, caramel. Oh’ sweet, Caramel. There’s not much to tell you, other than the fact that I love you. Sometimes. You see, caramel and I go way back. Way back to my junior high days when I actually discovered how to make caramel. It was a revolutionary moment to say the least. I brought a bag of it to a football game, and it’s safe to say that I was begged to bring it to every game there after. Who needs nachos, popcorn, and pizza when you have a sticky bag of caramel to munch on during a football game? Not us fourteen year olds, that’s for sure. I’m sure our parents didn’t appreciate the increasing dental bill, but heck. You only live once, right? (Cue dentures by 30 here.)Mini Caramel Cheesecake Bites

After high school, I lost my magic touch with caramel. It was the strangest thing. I literally could not get one batch to not turn rock solid. I’d like to think it was a faulty candy thermometer, but that might be stretching the story a bit. So as my caramel trials failed, so did my pride (I might tend to be overly dramatic when telling stories). It took me almost 4 years to try to make homemade caramel again. And when I did…three batches burnt in one day. You would have thought I would have stopped at the first batch, but no. Oh no. I was determined to make those caramel apples for a little Halloween party were were throwing in Italy, and I was not about to stop at failure. Until the third batch, and then at that point failure was my only option. Let’s just say that we had a nice big bowl of apples to get that party started.

Mini Caramel Cheesecake Bites | Design Eat Repeat Blog

So at this point, you are probably thinking I’m about to turn this story around and start telling you about my recent caramel success. But today, I left it up to the pros from Fat Toad Farm to do all the dirty work for the caramel used in these mini caramel cheesecake bites. I had contacted this family-run farm a while back seeing if they would be interested in having me develop a recipe using their Goat’s Milk Caramel. Why? Because A.) I had never tried anything with goat’s milk, and I was a curious cat. And B.) It looked like heaven in a jar. Which to me are two good reasons for this unadventurous taster to try something new.

Mini Caramel Cheesecake Bites | Design Eat Repeat

The verdict? Heaven in liquid form. Like I said before, I was a bit hesitant at first because the words “goat milk” makes me a little leery.  I don’t like regular milk, so basically, anything with the word milk gives me second thoughts. Unless it’s milk chocolate, and then in that case, pour it on me. The original caramel jar I used gave the cheesecake bites a more tangy taste than the caramel I was used to making (or tried to make). It was a nice switch up from what I was used to, and the bites were a hit. Can you really go wrong with cheesecake bites smothered with thick & creamy caramel? Didn’t think so.

Mini Caramel Cheesecake Bites from Design Eat Repeat

Mini Caramel Cheesecake Bites
Serves: 12 bites
  • 1 (8 oz) package cream cheese, softened
  • 1 egg
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla
  • ¼ cup sugar
  • ¼ cup Fat Toad Original Caramel or favorite carmel topping

  • Crust:
  • 1 cup graham cracker crumbs
  • 2 tablespoons brown sugar
  • ½ stick butter, melted

  • Optional Topping:
  • ¼ cup Fat Toad Original Caramel or favorite carmel topping
  1. In a small bowl, combine graham cracker crumbs, brown sugar, and melted butter. Stir until combined and evenly distribute mixture between 12 lined mini muffin tin. Press down with hands until each is firmly packed down.
  2. In another large bowl, beat together cream cheese, egg, vanilla, and sugar with an electric mixer for 30 seconds. Once combined, fold in caramel.
  3. Spoon or pipe mixture into each muffin tin. Each muffin tin should be ½ to ¾ full.
  4. Bake at 375 degrees for 13-15 minutes. Remove from oven and allow them to cool before topping with caramel. I prefer to refrigerate cheesecake before serving, so you can wait to top with caramel until after refrigeration.

 Have you ever tried making homemade caramel? Was it a good experience? Or traumatizing-never-do-it-again experience?

 * Disclaimer: I was provided a complimentary product to review. All opinions expressed are my own & no compensation was provided.

  1. says

    Delicious! Great minds think alike =o) I just posted Salted Caramel Mini Cheesecakes =o) We made caramel sauce and it was amazing. It’s going to be hard to go back to store bought after this. I love that you put caramel in your cheesecakes. Totally going to do that next time!

  2. says

    OMG! I love these! …I could easily eat…quite a few lol.

    Found your site through Full Plate Thursday. Hope you stop by soon!

    Tammy (& Catherine) of Living the Gourmet

  3. says

    I love everything mini and these cheesecakes look so fabulous! Thanks for linking up with What’s Cookin’ Wednesday!

    • says

      Hey Briana! The caramel I used in this recipe was jarred caramel from Fat Toad Farm. If I master creamy caramel like them, I’ll let you know :)

  4. kady says

    what does it mean “fold in caramel?” how much caramel do i “fold in?” and how do i “fold” in caramel to a graham cup???

    • says

      Hi Kady! Folding is just a method of gently stirring the batter. It helps create a “swirl” effect with the caramel and folding is generally used when you don’t want to overmix something. (Here’s a YouTube video that might help!)

      Once the mixture is stirred, you simply spoon the batter into the graham cracker cups. Hopefully this helps!

    • says

      Yes, that shouldn’t be a problem! I’ve frozen cheesecake before. I would just hold off on drizzling the caramel topping until after you freeze/thaw them. Here’s the link I usually follow when storing cheesecake. Hope that helps!

  5. Joe says

    Great recipe, making them for the second time for a birthday get together tomorrow. One note here, it says 12 bites, but I got 24 out of this recipe without having to double it.